10 signs you're an afternoon tea connoisseur

Afternoon tea, that very British favourite, gives rise to all sorts of tricky decisions

William Edwards Reed tea set
(Image credit: William Edwards)

Delectable scones accompanied by lashings of jam and cream; dainty finger sandwiches displayed elegantly on a tiered cake stand; a steaming pot of tea served in the finest china... there is nothing more quintessentially British than afternoon tea. It is hard to find anyone who isn't a fan. However, disagreements run rife – from controversial modern takes on the classic afternoon tea to the order in which to work your way through the feast. 

So, we thought, why not present Period Living's guide to serving up a traditional afternoon tea? Count up how many of the questions below you get right and you can see how you match up to your friends, and find out who in your group puts the milk in tea first or puts their jam on before cream... Find more gorgeous things to obsess over on our design hub page.

1. You get annoyed when people call it a 's-cone'?

The age-old pronunciation debate: is it 'scone' (as in 'gone') or 'scone' (as in 'cone')? In the UK the ‘gone’ scone just grabs the favourite spot, whereas the ‘stone’ scone is what sets US mouths watering.


2. You have very clear opinions when it comes to adding fruit to your scones?

There's no definite correct choice – plain or sultanas – but it's a question that causes culinary contention among fans of cream tea, but we’re not fussy… both please!


3. You know the difference between afternoon tea, royal tea and high tea?

Traditionally the term 'afternoon tea' refers to the ritual of taking tea with scones, cream, jam, finger sandwiches and cakes, but add a glass of Champagne and it is elevated to royal or royale tea – a popular choice on the menus of great British hotels and institutions.

At Fortnum & Mason you can even have a personalised message printed onto the label of your champagne. Afternoon tea and royal tea should not be confused with high tea, which historically was the main meal in a working class household, taken with a strong brew after a hard day’s labour.

Fortnum & Mason royal tea... looks yummy

4. You know the difference between Devonshire and Cornish afternoon tea?

If you prefer cream then jam, you align with the Cornish, while if you're adamant it's jam then cream, you're following Devonshire roots. 


Debrett’s etiquette experts favour the Cornish approach and there's definitely something aesthetically pleasing about the bright red jam on top of the cream, but this battle of the counties will run and run. 


5. You have your tea with milk or with lemon?

Generally speaking, black teas and robust, full-bodied blends such as English Breakfast, Assam and Ceylon are the ones usually taken with milk, although lemon is still agreeable with most black teas. However, many connoisseurs would say tea should be enjoyed unadulterated. Just make sure you never use milk and lemon at the same time, and don’t forget your lemon plate and fork!


6. You never eat your scone or cake with your fingers?

You know the rules! If you’re eating ice cream, custard or something soft use a spoon; if it’s cake or pastry, you use a fork. The only acceptable finger food is the appropriately named finger sandwich, which is perfectly designed to keep your fingers clean!

Cutlery commission customised cake fork

(Image credit: The Cutlery Commission)

7. You never stick your pinkie out when drinking your tea?

Debrett's has this advice: ‘When drinking tea, hold the handle of the teacup between your thumb and forefinger. Don't hold your little finger in the air.’


8. You prefer the traditional cucumber finger sandwiches to the more decadent smoked salmon?

Cucumber sandwiches are the particular favourite of Lady Bracknell in Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest, and who are we to argue with that grande dame’s idea of what’s right and proper? Now you just have to decide whether it’s crusts on or off…


9. Nothing beats crisp white table linen?

Professional afternoon tea connoisseurs would favour the former, complete with a fresh pressed napkin for each setting. But we’d be quite happy with a vintage floral curtain picked up from a charity shop for a quirky rather than classy look! That said, who can resist this set up from Bettys?


10. You always put your milk in last?

This is a question that has long divided tea drinkers. Historically milk was often poured first to prevent the boiling water from cracking the china in poor quality cups. However, the introduction of finer quality china meant that this was no longer necessary, so milk started being added after, a tradition that became preferred by the upper classes as it signified that they owned the highest quality tableware.

Today most Brits still prefer the MIL method, possibly because it’s easier to judge the hue of your brew!

Biscuiteers afternoon tea

(Image credit: Biscuiteers)

Let's face it, we don't all have time to rustle up a tiered afternoon feast, but Biscuiteers' beautiful treats are an easy way to make tea time extra fancy. We're sure dunking would be frowned upon, but your secret's safe with us!

How much of a cream tea expert are you?

Count up the points below to find out how much of an afternoon tea expert you are:

1-3: Have you even ever had an afternoon tea?
4-6: Not bad, but maybe don't book your trip to Betty's just yet.
7-8: Perfect! Get planning your next trip now.
9-10: You're definitely a member of high-society – you've probably already got the scones warming.


Karen Darlow
After a brief foray into music journalism, fashion and beauty, Karen found herself right at home working on interior magazines with her role on Ideal Home magazine. She is now Homes Editor on Period Living magazine and loves the opportunity the job gives her to see how others mix vintage style and modern furnishings in their beautiful properties.